Where did a Jefferson County family keep its meat in 1926, before home refrigeration was common? In Monticello, families could rent a cold-storage locker from Felix and Alice Johnston, who ran a grocery store and refrigerated meat-locker business there. That business is now Johnston's Meat Market, and in its 100th year it is opening a second location at 3628 Shamrock Street West, in Killearn Village Square.
For Killearn Estates, the Shamrock store will be a starter version of the original. The owner has said it will open smaller than the Monticello market and grow from there. So the store's first few months will look like a butcher counter with Johnston's name on it. The full market, grill included, stays on West Washington Street in Monticello for now.
From meat lockers to dry-aged beef
The way the business grew explains what it sells today. WTXL reported that over the decades Johnston's went from renting meat lockers to running a full-service market that covers everything from meat processing to homemade goods. Tallahassee Reports wrote that it became known across North Florida for fresh cuts, smoked sausage and other country-smoked products.
The business has had very few owners in that time:
| Year | What happened |
|---|---|
| 1926 | Felix and Alice Johnston open a grocery and refrigerated meat-locker business in Monticello |
| Three generations | The Johnston family runs the business |
| 2022 | Patrick Figueroa joins as general manager |
| 2024 | Figueroa buys the company, becoming its fourth owner |
| July 29, 2026 | A city commercial permit application is filed for the Tallahassee location |
| Late Aug. to mid-Sept. 2026 | Local outlets report the Killearn Village Square store |
The owner's statements line up with that history. In a 2025 feature, WTXL quoted Figueroa saying he wanted to keep the recipes and traditions the market had built over 99 years. Speaking with WTXL again in September 2026, he described the expansion as being about family and legacy more than growth.
What the Shamrock counter is expected to carry
None of the coverage gives a final product list for the Tallahassee store. What it does give is Figueroa's word, reported by WTXL, that the new shop will carry the same products and offer the same experience as the original. Based on what the Monticello store is known for, here is what that likely covers:
- Dry-aged beef. Figueroa told WTXL the shop specializes in beef aged between 14 and 30 days.
- Custom and fresh cuts. Tallahassee Reports described the Killearn store as a nearby place to buy fresh meats, custom cuts and smoked products without going to a supermarket.
- Smoked and breakfast sausage. A longtime customer who lives and works nearby told WTXL that the market's smoked sausage and breakfast sausage are a staple in his house.
- Local pantry goods. WCTV reported that Johnston's also sells local goods such as honey and jams.
Figueroa told WTXL the shop has a "farm-to-table kind of feel." WCTV quoted him saying the expansion is "all about getting good American beef into our people in Tallahassee." Neither report names specific ranches, so the reporting doesn't say where the beef comes from beyond that.
The "smaller at first" detail matters most for the counter itself. On WTXL, Figueroa put it this way: "It's going to be a little smaller at first, and then we'll continue to expand. But they're going to get the same culture, the same, you know, happy faces and the great meat." Expect the first case on Shamrock to be a narrower selection of the same products, with more space and variety added later.
Two opening targets and a license
There are two published timelines, and they come from reports a week apart.
- September 4, 2026. WCTV reported that construction and renovation were still underway at Killearn Village Square, with the work expected to finish by the end of the year and the store opening soon after.
- September 11, 2026. WTXL reported that Figueroa hoped to open by the end of November, and that the shop was waiting on its license before finishing the build-out.
As of October 12, the end of November is about seven weeks off. Both dates are targets. We found no report after September 11 confirming that either one is holding, and the November date depends on a license that hadn't been issued when WTXL ran its story. The permit side is public: the City of Tallahassee's commercial review list shows permit TCB260425 for "Johnstons Meat Market Tallahassee Location" at 3628 Shamrock W, applied for on July 29, 2026. That record shows an application under review. It doesn't say when the doors will open.
The store is also expected to add jobs. WTXL said the expansion should bring jobs and economic activity to the area, and WCTV's story linked to an application through the business's social media. Neither outlet listed positions or a hiring schedule.
Where it sits on Shamrock
The Tallahassee Democrat placed the new shop in Killearn Village Square, next to Killearn Methodist Church and near The Country Flower Shop and Ming Tree Cafe. For a lot of households in the neighborhood, that puts dry-aged beef and house-smoked sausage on the same short drive as a flower order or takeout from Ming Tree.
The location is a change for regular customers, too. WCTV spoke with a Monticello regular who said that until now, getting Johnston's meant driving from Tallahassee to Monticello, because nothing closer compared. Tallahassee Reports called the move a significant expansion that brings Johnston's "know your butcher" philosophy to one of Tallahassee's largest established neighborhoods.
The full market is still in Monticello
Until Shamrock opens, and probably for a while after if the Killearn store starts small, the complete Johnston's is the original store. Its official site lists:
| Monticello store | |
|---|---|
| Address | 1480 W. Washington St., Monticello, FL 32344 |
| Shop hours | Monday to Friday, 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m.; Saturday, 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. |
| Southern Grill | Monday to Saturday, 11 a.m. to 2 p.m. |
The grill is the biggest difference between the two stores as reported so far. None of the coverage of the Killearn location mentions a grill or lunch service. For lunch with your order, Monticello is still the only option. The Saturday morning hours at 8 a.m. suit a weekend trip, since that's the only day the shop opens before 10.
The Killearn opening date could still move depending on when the license comes through and the build-out finishes, so watch for the next local report.
Once the doors open on Shamrock, a lot of Killearn Estates households will have a hundred-year-old butcher a few minutes from home. If you're curious what yours is worth this season, Titus Nixon can run a free home valuation or sit down with you to talk it through. Let's connect.